i can’t help but share this. it hit me like a ton of bricks. the follow is an encounter brian mclaren had at davos a few weeks ago.
Another moment – when a Muslim conversation partner introduced me to
a group of Muslims I hadn’t met: "This is my friend, Brian." When
people stop being "that Jew" or "that Christian" or "that Muslim," and
instead become "my friend," followed by a real name … the state of the
world improves a little bit.And another – sitting with a Muslim scholar who explained to me, "If
you want to understand our struggle, think of your own Declaration of
Independence." She rehearsed the lines, known by heart: "… we hold
these truths to be self-evident … created equal … endowed by their
Creator with certain inalienable rights." She asked me what these lines
were intended to do, to accomplish. I replied, "To counter the
pre-modern notion of the divine right of kings with a new notion – of
the God-given rights of individuals." Why, she asked, was it important
to bring God in? "Because God represents an authority higher than a
king’s authority. If God gives individuals rights, a king loses his
right to abrogate them."Then she said, "This is a primary reason why there is such a
religious revival in Islam. Millions of Muslims live under
dictatorships. They need to have their human rights validated
theologically so they can gain freedom from dictators, just as American
colonists wanted to gain freedom from the king in 1776." Sadly, she
added, many of these dictators have remained in power with U.S.
support, which helps explain much of the antipathy toward U.S. foreign
policy. A simple thought, perhaps obvious to many, but it clicked for
me as never before.
1. i like how brian explains the declaration of independence, that God is above kings. so it is no surprise that in that it hit like a ton of bricks… why do we enable other countries to live in a framework that we would not allow ourselves to be in. i am not advocating nation building, like we are experiencing in Afghanistan or Iraq, certainly we did much to help them to where they were. but what if there were other creative means to enable all people to live where God is ultimate authority? even over that of a king or president? hmm..
Except that whenever a Muslim country has an open and free election, they tend to put the most repressive people into power. Egypt, Palestine, Lebanon.
When the Iranians revolted against their American backed dictator, the Shah, they put a government in place that was ten times more oppressive.
I think this argument does not hold water because it ignores the last several decades of world history.
Except that whenever a Muslim country has an open and free election, they tend to put the most repressive people into power. Egypt, Palestine, Lebanon.
When the Iranians revolted against their American backed dictator, the Shah, they put a government in place that was ten times more oppressive.
I think this argument does not hold water because it ignores the last several decades of world history.
good point thomas, in the case of Iran, is that partial to the angst against the US? similar to the cries of “anybody but…”
i think too, you have people who do not know how to lead in a democratic society, which comes from hundreds of years of historic rule.
something to think about.
good point thomas, in the case of Iran, is that partial to the angst against the US? similar to the cries of “anybody but…”
i think too, you have people who do not know how to lead in a democratic society, which comes from hundreds of years of historic rule.
something to think about.